Posted by John McDonough on March 27, 1999 at 01:48:49:
In Reply to: Re:Plots and Movies posted by Irina Liedtke on March 24, 1999 at 18:38:25:
: When I read my first Jack Vance novel, Araminta Station, four years ago, my initial feeling was that someone should make it into a movie. I felt it had an intricate plot with many subtleties, and now am inclined to think that the entire Cadwal series would be great on screen. I am anxious to know who any of you Vance fans would cast for Glawen Clattuc. In regards to casting Arnold Schwarzenager in the role of Kirth Gersen, I vote nay. His accent would ruin every line, not to mention the fact that Gersen is described as spare. Sure Arnold is tough, he's the strong and silent type because his delivery of any significant line is RARELY taken seriously (ie: get your ass to Mars...) Gersen knows street fighting and martial arts, which Arnold seems too buff to pull off with any speed or finesse. I can see Gwyneth Paltrow as Suldren, but Leonard Nemoy as Cugel-besides his convincing hair-do, how old is the guy anyway? I think I can see Val Kilmer playing the part...
: Of course it's amusing to ponder a JV coming to life before our very eyes, but lets face it, too often we are disappointed when a novel is brought to the screen. I would hold my breath through the whole thing, hoping it didn't taint any scenes that I am able to image so beautifully thanks to Vance's lyrical prose.
: Irina
I quick casting from my wife and I,
Glawen - Matthew Broderick (mischievious, loveble and gutsy)
Wayness - Winona Ryder (mousey, cute, petite but resourceful)
Also Michael Biehn for Gersen (sorry can't see Arnold in that role)
Regards,
John & Lea-Anne