Posted by Bob Justice on March 23, 1999 at 06:39:28:
In Reply to: Movies? Never! posted by David Pierce on March 22, 1999 at 22:13:00:
: Spare us from years of having Vance books made into "pictures." Jack's words are feelie-like in their utilization of our senses; could they be translated to film via cinematography, it is doubtful they'd elevate the craft--no matter how skillfull the production. At best such an undertaking would only achieve the status of "Vance Lite." And can you imagine hearing folks say, "I ain't read the book but I seen the flick." Argh! Jack himself eschews movies, and the curmodgeon probably does so with good reason.
: Dean, Bob, and others: You are obviously lads of wit and resource; is it possible that, with the rarefied inspiration of Vance in your heads, you could invent your own live-action or animated films? I bet you have the talent.
: Jack Vance is no Shakespeare, nor even an Apollon Zamp; his writings are effective when read silently or aloud, but were never meant for the stage or screen. However: it might be amusing to see staged a version of "The Legend Of Emphyrio."
: David Pierce
I agree. I think you would run into the same problem David Lynch had with Dune or Stanly Kubrick had with 2001. Except for a few science fiction buffs no one would understand the movie.